Real World Maths Busters

The Maths Behind Everyday Life

The story, the formula and a worked example — see exactly where this maths shows up in the world around you.

Back to all stories
Games & Chance 3 min read

Should you switch doors? (The Monty Hall puzzle)

The answer feels wrong — but switching doubles your chance of winning.

On a game show, a prize hides behind one of three doors. You pick one; the host, who knows where the prize is, opens a different door to reveal a goat and offers you the chance to switch. It feels like a 50-50 coin flip. It is not.

Your first pick is probably wrong

When you first choose, you have a 1 in 3 chance of being right — so a 2 in 3 chance the prize is behind one of the other two doors. The host opening a goat door does not change your original odds.

P(win by switching)=23P(\text{win by switching}) = \tfrac{2}{3}

Where the 2/3 goes

Follow the probability after the host reveals a goat.

Stay versus switch

  1. 1

    Chance your first door is right

    1/31/3
  2. 2

    Chance the prize was elsewhere

    2/32/3
  3. 3

    Switching collects that 2/3

    The host removed the losing option, concentrating the 2/3 onto the remaining door.

Answer

Switch every time: it wins 2 out of 3, while staying wins only 1 out of 3.

The takeaway

The host's knowledge is the twist — their choice is not random, so it feeds you information. Switching turns a 1/3 game into a 2/3 one.

Back to all stories