Real World Maths Busters

The Maths Behind Everyday Life

The story, the formula and a worked example — see exactly where this maths shows up in the world around you.

Back to all stories
Games & Chance 3 min read

Under-Promotion: When a Queen Is Wrong

Sometimes a knight is better.

In chess, promoting a pawn to a queen is almost always best. But in rare positions, a knight promotion gives check or avoids stalemate — under-promotion wins the game.

When to under-promote

A knight promotion is correct when the queen would cause stalemate or the knight gives a winning fork.

Vknight promo>Vqueen promo when stalemate or forkV_{\text{knight promo}} > V_{\text{queen promo}} \text{ when stalemate or fork}

King on h1, pawn on g7, opponent king on f2

  1. 1

    Queen promo

    g8=Q+ looks natural

  2. 2

    But

    After Kf1, queen may not force mate quickly

  3. 3

    Knight promo

    g8=N+ forks king and rook on e7

  4. 4

    Result

    Win rook, then win game

Answer

Knight promotion forks king and rook — far better than a queen in this position

The formula behind it

Combinations

(nr)=n!r!(n−r)!\binom{n}{r} = \frac{n!}{r!(n-r)!}
See the full formula, variables and more examples

The takeaway

Under-promotion happens roughly once in 2,000 games — rare but game-deciding.

Back to all stories