Real World Maths Busters

The Maths Behind Everyday Life

The story, the formula and a worked example — see exactly where this maths shows up in the world around you.

Back to all stories
Games & Chance 3 min read

When to Block in Catan

Expected resource denial.

Placing a road or settlement to block an opponent denies them future resources. The value of blocking equals the expected resources they lose per turn.

Blocking value

Value = P(number rolled) × resources denied.

Vblock=dots on number36×resources deniedV_{\text{block}} = \frac{\text{dots on number}}{36} \times \text{resources denied}

Blocking access to an 8-spot (5 dots) with wheat and ore

  1. 1

    P(8 rolled)

    5/36 = 13.9%

  2. 2

    Resources denied

    1 wheat + 1 ore per roll

  3. 3

    Per 36 rolls

    5 wheat + 5 ore denied

  4. 4

    Value

    Significant if opponent needs wheat for cities

Answer

Blocking a 5-dot hex denies ~0.14 resources per roll — worth it against the leader

The formula behind it

Expected Value

E(X)=∑xi⋅P(xi)E(X) = \sum x_i \cdot P(x_i)
See the full formula, variables and more examples

The takeaway

Block when the denial value exceeds the opportunity cost of placing your piece elsewhere.

Back to all stories