Real World Maths Busters

The Maths Behind Everyday Life

The story, the formula and a worked example — see exactly where this maths shows up in the world around you.

Back to all stories
Games & Chance 4 min read

Auction Winner’s Curse

Why the winner often overpays.

If 10 bidders each estimate a painting’s value, the highest estimate is likely above the true value. The more bidders, the worse the curse.

The bias

The expected overpayment increases with the number of bidders.

E[winning bid−true value]∝σln⁡nE[\text{winning bid} - \text{true value}] \propto \sigma \sqrt{\ln n}

10 bidders, true value $100k, σ = $20k

  1. 1

    Step

    Expected max estimate ≈ $100k + $20k × √(ln 10)

  2. 2

    Step

    ≈ $100k + $20k × 1.52 = $130,400

Answer

Winner overpays by ~$30k on average

Optimal response

Shade your bid below your estimate by an amount that increases with bidder count.

The formula behind it

Expected Value

E(X)=∑xi⋅P(xi)E(X) = \sum x_i \cdot P(x_i)
See the full formula, variables and more examples

The takeaway

The winner’s curse: in auctions, winning can be the worst outcome.

Back to all stories